HOW CAN YOU IDENTIFY A QUALIFIED DIETITIAN?
At present, there is no local statutory registration for dietitians in Hong Kong. Therefore anyone can call themselves a dietitian or nutritionist. Some people may call themselves as “nutrition consultant”, “professional nutritionist”, “nutrition expert”, “nutrition chef”, “nutria-beautician” and “slimming nutritionist” etc. even though they do not possess adequate qualifications. They may provide incorrect or biased dietary recommendations to coax consumers to buy expensivenutrition products.
In order to assist the public to identify qualified dietitians to provide medical nutrition therapy, HKDA provides an online list of “Accredited Dietitians”. If any consumer is in doubt, relevantproof of qualification should be requested from the healthcare professional to protect the consumer’s own rights and health. https://www.hkda.com.hk/index.php?_a=viewDoc&docId=27
話說小弟喺清明開左個關於香港營養師學會嘅post
就引嚟咗少少討論咁
https://lihkg.com/thread/617473/page/1
然後咁朝一起身就有巴打發現kathy嗰邊就打左個Q&A
咁細佬我就循例講吓佢回應咗啲咩啦
淨係回應少少,其他Q&A都係自sell,不理也罷
Q1. Nutritionist和Dietitian兩者都普遍稱作「營養師」,兩者有甚麼分別?香港政府有官方註冊制度嗎?
A1. 直至現時為止,香港政府並沒有官方註冊制度為Nutritionist或Dietitian進行法定註冊,任何人皆可以自稱為 營養師 / Nutritionist / Dietitian。
Vannesa絲打表示:
on9,dietitian 點會自稱nutritionist 呀kathy姐,你肯佢地都唔肯啦,整cheap晒。而nutritionist唔會自稱dietitian 係因為自道自己係呃飯食囉
我嘅補充:
仲以為有專業資格先可以叫執業人士
執乜撚嘢業呀,執葉就有佢份
另外,佢話nutritionist同dietitian無凌駕性
梗係無凌駕性啦
一個有牌一個無牌 dont know 凌駕what
Q3. Nutritionist專業在外國的認受性如何?
A3. 西方國家例如英國以及澳洲,都有機構分開為Nutritionist和Dietitian兩個專業進行註冊。例如英國的 'Association for Nutrition' (http://www.associationfornutrition.org/ ), 以及澳洲的'The Nutrition Society of Australia'(http://nsa.asn.au/ ) 。
我嘅回應:
Dietitian喺澳洲嘅移民list有,nutritionist無
另外,nutritionist係無接受過專業訓練,dont know where 專業
Si7dan絲打爆料:
我地year 3 summer大部分都會揀做intern去fulfil 個capstone course,kathy就逢呢個時候會send email比我地,叫我地去做。
去到interview係見佢老公嘅,佢全程係咁吹噓自己有幾撚把炮,但明明自己都唔撚係讀food nu嘅
講到nutritionist同dietitian有得比,甚至叻過佢咁,話咩 如果唔係啊,我地一早執咗啦
雖然冇乜intern揀,不過見到佢寸過馬撚咁嘅樣,真係做lit都唔屌你份工
每年淨係收一個intern,好彩嘅嗰個人咪會做佢啲咩徒弟囉
聽人講啲咩蘋果黎做訪問,淨係比個topic啲徒弟,啊徒弟自己揾資料,連記者問咩問題都要個徒弟自己諗
呀kathy姐,你明唔明點解我要狙擊你呀?
因為你自己set up咗個學會認可自己做認可營養師誤導公眾呀
你咁玩法,唔狙擊你狙擊邊個
讀個degree就叫營養學家/營養師,咁讀個phy bsc就叫物理學家/動物傳心師啦屌