計劃進修PhD/Research討論區 (9) 以有涯隨無涯殆已

寶可夢博士 2017-4-9 15:52:39

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

A research sample is a better signal than GPA

:^(

如果得一個位，
一個gpa3.9無文，一個gpa3.2有Q1文，咁會點揀
:^(

仲有會睇research interest 夾唔夾
出既文係咪岩自己個field

姐係都係傾向揀有文？如果佢岩interest

多數揀有人
近排班老細覺得高gpa既都未必識寫文
我個系有人呢一年無寫過文

:^(

出身於某間英國名牌大學

寶寶不乖 2017-4-9 15:53:32

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

寶可夢博士 2017-4-9 15:54:09

無知一問 review paper係咪易寫好多?
:^(

好撚難寫
我最近掟左一份點知個editor要我交cv and publication list
等佢同reviewer 判斷我係咪係呢個field既expert

:^(
越改越難

玩都咁激！
尋日先同同事討論過呢個問題
我覺得呢d review 唔一定要由expert 先寫到
但新手一定用多好多時間
但只要推論引證係正確
我唔覺得你同expert 會有咩差別

Reputation bias
:^(

:^(

:^(

擺到明留難我
宜家under review
睇黎都凶多吉少

我做緊個新field
我師傅都唔算係domain expert
我更加唔洗講

傳教士谷哥 2017-4-9 15:54:44

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

有無啲咩例子

:^(

一言筆發 2017-4-9 15:54:49

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

大膠神 2017-4-9 15:56:06

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

婆你呀麼 2017-4-9 15:56:11

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

一言筆發 2017-4-9 15:56:40

無知一問 review paper係咪易寫好多?
:^(

好撚難寫
我最近掟左一份點知個editor要我交cv and publication list
等佢同reviewer 判斷我係咪係呢個field既expert

:^(
越改越難

玩都咁激！
尋日先同同事討論過呢個問題
我覺得呢d review 唔一定要由expert 先寫到
但新手一定用多好多時間
但只要推論引證係正確
我唔覺得你同expert 會有咩差別

Reputation bias
:^(

:^(

:^(

擺到明留難我
宜家under review
睇黎都凶多吉少

我做緊個新field
我師傅都唔算係domain expert
我更加唔洗講

invite 個field expert 做 co author
好多人都係咁做

傳教士谷哥 2017-4-9 15:57:05

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

No

http://www.ugc.edu.hk/eng/rgc/funding_opport/general_research_fund/application.html#eligibility

Effective from funding exercises for 2007/08, only academic staff members whose conditions of employment meet all the following requirements are eligible for application of RGC grants as Principal Investigator (PI):

they have a full-time1 appointment in the institution proper2 of UGC-funded institutions;

they are in Staff Grades from 'A' to 'I'3 (i.e. from 'Professor' to 'Assistant Lecturer');

they are primarily engaged in and spend at least 80% of their time in degree or higher degree work at the institution proper; and

their salary is wholly funded4 by the institution proper.

:^(

原來係咁
其實有無咩funding可以唔洗faculty member或者街外人都申請得架

:^(

數學廢柴 2017-4-9 15:57:10

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

:^(

一言筆發 2017-4-9 15:57:20

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

見到，唔該

一言筆發 2017-4-9 15:58:09

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

No

http://www.ugc.edu.hk/eng/rgc/funding_opport/general_research_fund/application.html#eligibility

Effective from funding exercises for 2007/08, only academic staff members whose conditions of employment meet all the following requirements are eligible for application of RGC grants as Principal Investigator (PI):

they have a full-time1 appointment in the institution proper2 of UGC-funded institutions;

they are in Staff Grades from 'A' to 'I'3 (i.e. from 'Professor' to 'Assistant Lecturer');

they are primarily engaged in and spend at least 80% of their time in degree or higher degree work at the institution proper; and

their salary is wholly funded4 by the institution proper.

:^(
原來係咁
其實有無咩funding可以唔洗faculty member或者街外人都申請得架
:^(

香港邊有
所以我都話唔好係香港做research

婆你呀麼 2017-4-9 15:59:33

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

:^(

algorithm競賽 pde又咁多combination

大膠神 2017-4-9 16:00:44

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

No

http://www.ugc.edu.hk/eng/rgc/funding_opport/general_research_fund/application.html#eligibility

Effective from funding exercises for 2007/08, only academic staff members whose conditions of employment meet all the following requirements are eligible for application of RGC grants as Principal Investigator (PI):

they have a full-time1 appointment in the institution proper2 of UGC-funded institutions;

they are in Staff Grades from 'A' to 'I'3 (i.e. from 'Professor' to 'Assistant Lecturer');

they are primarily engaged in and spend at least 80% of their time in degree or higher degree work at the institution proper; and

their salary is wholly funded4 by the institution proper.

:^(
原來係咁
其實有無咩funding可以唔洗faculty member或者街外人都申請得架
:^(

WYNG foundation?

傳教士谷哥 2017-4-9 16:00:55

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

:^(

HCPF好似都可以match 下psycho

:^(

數學廢柴 2017-4-9 16:01:35

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

:^(

婆你呀麼 2017-4-9 16:02:32

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

:^(

:^(

J痕叔叔 2017-4-9 16:04:53

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

A research sample is a better signal than GPA

:^(

如果得一個位，
一個gpa3.9無文，一個gpa3.2有Q1文，咁會點揀
:^(

仲有會睇research interest 夾唔夾
出既文係咪岩自己個field

姐係都係傾向揀有文？如果佢岩interest

umm. 叫做有多d 機會可以interview 囉

睇下你apply個program大唔大。
呢兩種情況係我以前同班同學都有(唔係high quality papers, 但係叫publication)
最尾係gpa低個條友比gpa高個條友先grad

:^(

數學廢柴 2017-4-9 16:04:53

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

:^(

:^(

algorithm競賽 pde又咁多combination

所以PDE appears a.e. in department of math

:^(

大膠神 2017-4-9 16:05:40

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

:^(

HCPF好似都可以match 下psycho
:^(

https://rfs1.fhb.gov.hk/images/HCPF/2016_HCPF_ThematicPriorities_eng.pdf
如果中到佢d Thematic Priorities會易d中
如果偏向clinical psy的話HMRF都有機會得

傳教士谷哥 2017-4-9 16:06:06

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

A research sample is a better signal than GPA

:^(

如果得一個位，
一個gpa3.9無文，一個gpa3.2有Q1文，咁會點揀
:^(

仲有會睇research interest 夾唔夾
出既文係咪岩自己個field

姐係都係傾向揀有文？如果佢岩interest

umm. 叫做有多d 機會可以interview 囉

睇下你apply個program大唔大。
呢兩種情況係我以前同班同學都有(唔係high quality papers, 但係叫publication)
最尾係gpa低個條友比gpa高個條友先grad
:^(

:^(

但唔知admission會係點

:^(

J痕叔叔 2017-4-9 16:06:17

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

一日要寫幾多張

:^(

傳教士谷哥 2017-4-9 16:08:14

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

:^(

HCPF好似都可以match 下psycho
:^(

https://rfs1.fhb.gov.hk/images/HCPF/2016_HCPF_ThematicPriorities_eng.pdf
如果中到佢d Thematic Priorities會易d中
如果偏向clinical psy的話HMRF都有機會得

見佢mental well being, internet, 都幾psycho下

btw, psychi好似真係易啲，但唔多想玩太illness果啲

:^(

一言筆發 2017-4-9 16:10:03

有無巴打成功apply過external funding/scholarship? 你地按咩criteria去寫到說服到committee?
:^(

搭單問，其實RGC啲research funding 是咪一定要係大專院校既人先可以申請？自己就咁submit個proposal得唔得架

香港？好似唔得
pi 一定要係大學
好似係

上邊我貼左，RGC必須要係大學
HMRF/HCPF呢d就無呢個限制

:^(

HCPF好似都可以match 下psycho
:^(

https://rfs1.fhb.gov.hk/images/HCPF/2016_HCPF_ThematicPriorities_eng.pdf
如果中到佢d Thematic Priorities會易d中
如果偏向clinical psy的話HMRF都有機會得

好似比較偏向community psychology/ epidemiology
如果係做psychopathology
應該申請會唔成功

寶可夢博士 2017-4-9 16:11:49

點解你地報phd都要有pub咁chur
:^(

:^(

冇pub咪畀人reject
:^(

pure math都係睇有無大粒野推薦姐, 反正99.9%都唔會有pub, 一係就垃圾
:^(

其實pure math d prof是咪都好少文？
:^(

平均每人一年會有幾多架？
:^(

好睇咩topic同個prof出紙個心態
:^(

PDE 果D會易D出紙, 同埋比較容易有人cite (有D仲可能係physics engine etc.)

:^(

一日要寫幾多張
:^(

:^(

:^(