計劃進修PhD/Research討論區 (5)
Adam_Smith 2017-3-22 08:29:44
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多

好似我而家d research, 其實都係傾之後自己搵方法做,佢咁樣其實係為你好
:^(
訓練你做一個independent researcher

Ads

Adam_Smith 2017-3-22 08:30:10
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Agger
:^(
:^(
PhM 2017-3-22 08:38:41 準備好呢個summer唔去trip,爆盡d essays & dissertation
:^(
J痕叔叔 2017-3-22 08:38:44
Optimization 其實學乜野
:^(

點optimize某objective subject to 唔同constraint (equality or inequality)
幾時有solution, 點計呀etc
深啲既有dynamic optimization, decision making over time etc.

like high school finding local maximum pt/minimum pt

Dynamic programming
:^(
:^(
:^(

讀緊game theory,入面有好多simplex optimization,用手計計到頭暈
:^(

Agger 好煩
:^(
nash bargaining solution


Dynamic programming 已經好好做。
Behavioral econ 有啲咩multi-selves agent, dynamically inconsistent agent, 連dynamic programming 都唔apply,煩到嘔泡。
Nash bargaining 亦都係最簡單,有幾多relationship中的surplus只係按bargaining power分。

好在我唔係modeling個邊
:^(

optimization其實係好正既topic 我做緊machine learning research
Machine learning入面好多algorithm 都係solve optimization problems
當中會用到好多real analysis同functional analysis既techniques
最正個位係可以自己諗某啲algorithms去solve某一類optimization problems然後paper
:^(

functional 同 real analysis 都好正
:^(

巴打講多啲
:^(
QM有好多banach space,想知多啲functional analysis做啲咩
:^(

我d FA已經唔記得七七八八
:^(
, 我更加唔識物理
某D Linear PDE可以用functional analysis的方法去deduce d property
e.g. compact operators
又可以用黎construct measures, e.g. Haar measure
同埋functional analysis本身會deal with d Banach / Hilbert spaces, 但係數學本身都會遇到呢D spaces, e.g. space of continuous functions, L^p spaces等等
probability都會見到, e.g. weak convergence
所以functional analysis算係analysis的基礎野
:^(
又要準備溫書考qualifying
:^(
:^(
:^(

analysis好難讀
:^(
巴打一定好醒目
:^(
:^(

我只係數學系的地底泥
:^(


我有本Rudin Functional,一頁都未睇過
:^(
Афанасий 2017-3-22 08:38:57
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Exactly
相反,俾好晒topic你,剩叫你做execution做幾年就有學位既,濟都唔好濟
:^(
Michaelzaki 2017-3-22 08:39:22
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Agger
:^(
:^(

除左自學 仲有自己搵人教你
:^(
:^(
J痕叔叔 2017-3-22 08:41:43
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Agger
:^(
:^(

除左自學 仲有自己搵人教你
:^(
:^(


Google是我良伴
:^(
:^(
PhM 2017-3-22 08:43:04 有無巴打本身係哲學底/研究哲學/個題目比較philosophical d?
:^(
chisinlo 2017-3-22 08:51:56
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Exactly
相反,俾好晒topic你,剩叫你做execution做幾年就有學位既,濟都唔好濟
:^(


聽呀sir話佢MIT嗰陣,條友姐係比左嗰field佢地,成個group都係嗰個題目。然後自己玩幾年
:^(
chisinlo 2017-3-22 08:53:16
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Exactly
相反,俾好晒topic你,剩叫你做execution做幾年就有學位既,濟都唔好濟
:^(


聽呀sir話佢MIT嗰陣,條友姐係比左嗰field佢地,成個group都係嗰個題目。然後自己玩幾年
:^(

淨係
:^(
Афанасий 2017-3-22 08:58:22
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Agger
:^(
:^(

除左自學 仲有自己搵人教你
:^(
:^(


Google是我良伴
:^(
:^(

不用分得那麼細,大家都是PhD in Google
:^(
:^(

Ads

Adam_Smith 2017-3-22 09:02:26
準備好呢個summer唔去trip,爆盡d essays & dissertation
:^(

早辛苦快d上岸
:^(
一言筆發 2017-3-22 09:36:22
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多


PhD正係要自學能力,有好多睇法同技術要自己develop。好的program最終係要訓練你成為independent researcher,吹到最大係你日後可以成一家之言。
所以prof係幫你係有難題時可以點你一下,而唔係比你完全依頼。

Agger
:^(
:^(

除左自學 仲有自己搵人教你
:^(
:^(


Google是我良伴
:^(
:^(

Google 直程係我良師
:^(
老卡拉馬佐夫 2017-3-22 10:29:39
回樓上幾位巴打:

其實我oxford個邊既formal offer letter未出...只係department比左informal offer letter我,話已經收左我,但未知supervisor會係邊個

不過我apply oxford個時 indicate左一個oxford prof做我supervisor
而個位oxford prof係我warwick supervisor讀phd個時既師父

個oxford prof收到我份application個時email過我warwick supervisor,問佢覺得我點
warwick supervisor亦都有寫好我

而呢個oxford prof係個field係超出名,比我warwick supervisor既名氣大好多

不過就算你去oxford唔去warwick 個prof都唔會嬲左你咁小氣掛
:^(

agger 而且你報得oxford而warwick個prof又知 都知你有機會去oxford啦
:^(

唔係串你但認真想問politics phd 有幾可去industry 做野
:^(
無乜可能既話點解要擔心街外人對校名既睇法
:^(

我明白做學術界 校名其次 research最緊要
但係我報ma既時候 我既professor話過校名對日後搵工都好緊要
佢個時PhD有更勁既學校收 但最後揀左Durham 因為同個邊既supervisor關係好
佢話"this has made his career much more difficult", and "I had to publish A LOT."

我唔係擔心街外人點睇,講真搵到教席最緊要,我concern既係學校reputation對之後搵教席既影響
:^(

最重要是校名! (指找教席)

乜唔係publication +network 咩
一言筆發 2017-3-22 10:30:47
回樓上幾位巴打:

其實我oxford個邊既formal offer letter未出...只係department比左informal offer letter我,話已經收左我,但未知supervisor會係邊個

不過我apply oxford個時 indicate左一個oxford prof做我supervisor
而個位oxford prof係我warwick supervisor讀phd個時既師父

個oxford prof收到我份application個時email過我warwick supervisor,問佢覺得我點
warwick supervisor亦都有寫好我

而呢個oxford prof係個field係超出名,比我warwick supervisor既名氣大好多

不過就算你去oxford唔去warwick 個prof都唔會嬲左你咁小氣掛
:^(

agger 而且你報得oxford而warwick個prof又知 都知你有機會去oxford啦
:^(

唔係串你但認真想問politics phd 有幾可去industry 做野
:^(
無乜可能既話點解要擔心街外人對校名既睇法
:^(

我明白做學術界 校名其次 research最緊要
但係我報ma既時候 我既professor話過校名對日後搵工都好緊要
佢個時PhD有更勁既學校收 但最後揀左Durham 因為同個邊既supervisor關係好
佢話"this has made his career much more difficult", and "I had to publish A LOT."

我唔係擔心街外人點睇,講真搵到教席最緊要,我concern既係學校reputation對之後搵教席既影響
:^(

最重要是校名! (指找教席)

乜唔係publication +network 咩

係香港可能校名重要d 既
成日請d 名校冇output 既人
傳教士谷哥 2017-3-22 10:45:14
回樓上幾位巴打:

其實我oxford個邊既formal offer letter未出...只係department比左informal offer letter我,話已經收左我,但未知supervisor會係邊個

不過我apply oxford個時 indicate左一個oxford prof做我supervisor
而個位oxford prof係我warwick supervisor讀phd個時既師父

個oxford prof收到我份application個時email過我warwick supervisor,問佢覺得我點
warwick supervisor亦都有寫好我

而呢個oxford prof係個field係超出名,比我warwick supervisor既名氣大好多

不過就算你去oxford唔去warwick 個prof都唔會嬲左你咁小氣掛
:^(

agger 而且你報得oxford而warwick個prof又知 都知你有機會去oxford啦
:^(

唔係串你但認真想問politics phd 有幾可去industry 做野
:^(
無乜可能既話點解要擔心街外人對校名既睇法
:^(

我明白做學術界 校名其次 research最緊要
但係我報ma既時候 我既professor話過校名對日後搵工都好緊要
佢個時PhD有更勁既學校收 但最後揀左Durham 因為同個邊既supervisor關係好
佢話"this has made his career much more difficult", and "I had to publish A LOT."

我唔係擔心街外人點睇,講真搵到教席最緊要,我concern既係學校reputation對之後搵教席既影響
:^(

最重要是校名! (指找教席)

乜唔係publication +network 咩

係香港可能校名重要d 既
成日請d 名校冇output 既人


打開d dept ge prof list就一堆, 除左有小小係三大, 其他咪臭係ivy UC, oxbridge, UCL, MIT, 或同級果D
:^(
美利堅帝國 2017-3-22 10:47:57 此回覆已被刪除
Adam_Smith 2017-3-22 10:58:48
文科讀PhD有咩做
齋睇書之後就出論文?

去領悟
:^(
Xetinemeth 2017-3-22 11:20:17
回樓上幾位巴打:

其實我oxford個邊既formal offer letter未出...只係department比左informal offer letter我,話已經收左我,但未知supervisor會係邊個

不過我apply oxford個時 indicate左一個oxford prof做我supervisor
而個位oxford prof係我warwick supervisor讀phd個時既師父

個oxford prof收到我份application個時email過我warwick supervisor,問佢覺得我點
warwick supervisor亦都有寫好我

而呢個oxford prof係個field係超出名,比我warwick supervisor既名氣大好多

不過就算你去oxford唔去warwick 個prof都唔會嬲左你咁小氣掛
:^(

agger 而且你報得oxford而warwick個prof又知 都知你有機會去oxford啦
:^(

唔係串你但認真想問politics phd 有幾可去industry 做野
:^(
無乜可能既話點解要擔心街外人對校名既睇法
:^(

我明白做學術界 校名其次 research最緊要
但係我報ma既時候 我既professor話過校名對日後搵工都好緊要
佢個時PhD有更勁既學校收 但最後揀左Durham 因為同個邊既supervisor關係好
佢話"this has made his career much more difficult", and "I had to publish A LOT."

我唔係擔心街外人點睇,講真搵到教席最緊要,我concern既係學校reputation對之後搵教席既影響
:^(

最重要是校名! (指找教席)

乜唔係publication +network 咩

係香港可能校名重要d 既
成日請d 名校冇output 既人


Department之前請左個oxbridge畢業嘅返嚟,兩年後炒左
:^(
Xetinemeth 2017-3-22 11:21:50
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多

好似我而家d research, 其實都係傾之後自己搵方法做,佢咁樣其實係為你好
:^(
訓練你做一個independent researcher


“Train you to be an independent researcher” 呢句我supervisor成日講
:^(
Adam_Smith 2017-3-22 11:36:32
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多

好似我而家d research, 其實都係傾之後自己搵方法做,佢咁樣其實係為你好
:^(
訓練你做一個independent researcher


“Train you to be an independent researcher” 呢句我supervisor成日講
:^(

所以我覺得愈放手既prof 同 supervisor, 其實係最好
:^(
但放手唔等於唔理/無視
:^(

Ads

Афанасий 2017-3-22 11:55:00
文科讀PhD有咩做
齋睇書之後就出論文?

去領悟
:^(

聽勁既historian講野,真係有種聽君一席話 勝讀十年書既感覺
:^(
Афанасий 2017-3-22 11:56:03
文科讀PhD有咩做
齋睇書之後就出論文?

去領悟
:^(

聽勁既historian講野,真係有種聽君一席話 勝讀十年書既感覺
:^(

仲有anthropologist
婆你呀麼 2017-3-22 12:02:21
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多

好似我而家d research, 其實都係傾之後自己搵方法做,佢咁樣其實係為你好
:^(
訓練你做一個independent researcher


“Train you to be an independent researcher” 呢句我supervisor成日講
:^(

所以我覺得愈放手既prof 同 supervisor, 其實係最好
:^(
但放手唔等於唔理/無視
:^(

岩呀 但係有d就無視當放手
:^(
chisinlo 2017-3-22 12:02:48
其實我而加讀緊ma既感覺都係prof比一大堆書你睇
唔會好詳細咁同你解D野
然後就寫文等佢比comment

好多時同自學無分別
:^(
去到PhD我估計要再independent得多

好似我而家d research, 其實都係傾之後自己搵方法做,佢咁樣其實係為你好
:^(
訓練你做一個independent researcher


“Train you to be an independent researcher” 呢句我supervisor成日講
:^(

所以我覺得愈放手既prof 同 supervisor, 其實係最好
:^(
但放手唔等於唔理/無視
:^(


:^(
:^(
:^(
FYP除左第一次meeting之後就係final presentation先見supervisor
:^(